Jamaican Jerk Pork Shoulder (Oven and Slow Cooker Instructions) (2024)

When you need to feed a crowd for your summer party, look no further than this Jamaican jerk pork shoulder! This succulent, ultra flavorful pork shoulder marinates in jerk spices overnight and then slowly roasts until it's melt-in-your-mouth tender. No summer gathering is complete without this tropical-inspired pork shoulder.

When it comes to summer entertaining, you can't go wrong with a perfectly roasted pork shoulder. This pork cut is large enough to feed lots of people, and it requires little hands-on preparation time for easy entertaining.

But you know what's even better than a roasted pork shoulder? A jerk-marinated pork shoulder! With a simple marinade, we can transform the humble pork shoulder into a Caribbean delight. The beach is my happy place, so I'm into any meal that tricks me into thinking I've escaped to the Caribbean.

I have a hunch your family and friends feel the same way. Who doesn't love a tropical getaway? So let's get into it and turn your casual backyard gathering into a piece of paradise.

Best Pork Cut for Slow Roasting

For this recipe, we use a pork shoulder as mentioned, but specifically, I recommend the pork butt cut as opposed to the picnic cut. The pork butt cut is still part of the pork shoulder, but it's higher on the foreleg and comes with more fat marbling. This makes for a more tender, flavorful dish. Pulled pork is typically made from the pork butt cut.

Could you use the picnic shoulder cut? Sure, just know that this recipe was created for the pork butt and recommended for best results.

When it comes to size, we have options here. Pork butts are usually sold in both small and large cuts, though the small cuts aren't necessarily small. Those "small" pork butt cuts weigh about 3 to 5 pounds. Compared to a 7- or 8-pound pork butt, this may be small, but it's still a lot of meat.

Expect to get about six to eight servings from the small cut while an 8-pound pork shoulder will produce approximately 10 to 12 servings. Another option is to get two 4-pound cuts and roast them in the same pan. I love this option because you get a lot of meat, but those smaller cuts cook in less time.

Step-by-Step Instructions

How to Make Jerk Marinade

Now that we settled on our pork cut, it's time to prepare our jerk marinade. For this step, we need a food processor or blender. Either one will work just fine.

To start, we throw in some habanero peppers, onion, ginger, garlic, dark brown sugar and spices into the food processor or blender. Traditionally, jerk marinade uses scotch bonnet peppers rather than habanero peppers, but they're difficult to find. Habanero peppers are close cousins and make a fine substitution, but feel free use scotch bonnet peppers if you're lucky enough to get your hands on them.

We give the food processor a whirl until the ingredients begin to roughly come together like so.

As the food processor runs, we add our liquid ingredients and blend. The mixture will smooth out, but some chunks will remain. That's normal.

We want to reserve ½ cup to 1 cup of marinade for injecting. The exact amount depends on the size of your meat. For a 3- to 5-pound pork butt, ½ cup marinade will do, but if you have anywhere from 6 to 8 pounds of meat, reserve a full cup.

We pour the rest of our marinade all over our pork, but before we do that, I like to cut small slits on top and underneath the pork. This allows the marinade to get into the meat for better flavor. As we spread the marinade over the pork, it helps to push some into those slits. Now we cover the pork and refrigerate overnight or up to 24 hours.

How to Roast Pork

And now for roasting! Before we start, I recommend covering the roasting pan with foil and giving the roasting rack a generous coating of cooking spray. Our pork shoulder will release a lot of delicious drippings as it cooks, and cleaning out the pan without foil is not a fun use of time.

Now we place the pork on our prepared roasting rack and start injecting the reserved marinade. Technically, this is an optional step, but I highly recommend it. Pork shoulder is such a big cut of meat, and injecting additional marinade helps maximize the flavor of the interior meat.

Tip: Because our marinade isn't perfectly smooth, a wide-mouth injector works best.

We place our pork in a 275-degree oven and cook uncovered until the internal temperature of the meat reaches 155-165 degrees F. At this point, we've reached what's known as the stall. This is when that wonderful fat marbling starts to render and causes the meat to stop rising in temperature.

To help our pork get past the stall, we remove it from the oven, wrap the roast with food-grade butcher paper or heavy-duty foil and place it back in the pan in the oven.

I've made this recipe many times, both wrapped and unwrapped, and in addition to helping the pork cook faster, wrapping makes for a moister meat. Speaking from experience, this step is well-worth the minimal effort.

From here, we roast the pork until it reaches a minimum internal temperature of 190 degrees F, but it's even better if you have the patience to let it hit 200-205 degrees F. For a small pork shoulder, eight hours takes care of the job pretty consistently, but plan for at least 10 hours and possibly up to 12 hours for a large pork roast. Keep in mind, every cut of meat cooks differently, so this is just a guideline.

Once the pork is tender and ready, we give it time to sit for at least 15 minutes before shredding — 30 minutes is even better. This allows the meat to redistribute its juices, ensuring our pork is perfectly moist.

Now we shred the meat, and we're ready to serve. Bonus points for serving a Jamaican rum mule on the side.

Bonus: Try this pork with my pineapple pico de gallo or mango-habanero salsa for an extra tropical touch!

Can You Make Jerk Pork in Slow Cooker?

If you can't give up your oven for as many hours as it takes to cook a pork butt, you can use a slow cooker. While I love the crust the oven gives this meat, the slow cooker also makes a delicious, tender pork butt.

To do this, place the marinated pork shoulder in a slow cooker with a cup of chicken stock and cook on low for eight hours. Keep in mind that slow cookers generally are too small to hold an 8-pound pork butt, so you only want to use this method for a pork butt under 5 pounds. Somewhere around 3 ½ pounds to 4 ½ pounds is good for the slow cooker.

How to Serve

If you'd like to keep it simple, I recommend serving this Jamaican jerk pork shoulder with a side of my coconut-lime rice and a homemade salsa. My jerk salsa, tropical pico de gallo or roasted tomato-chipotle salsa are all delicious accompaniments. Grilled corn is another delicious side option, and Successible Life has a great roundup of five different ways to make grilled corn on the cob in case you'd like some creative inspiration.

Another tropical option is to serve with my Hawaiian potato salad. While it isn't Jamaican, it still brings those island vibes.

Or you can use this Caribbean-inspired pork in so many other ways. Rather than chicken, use the pork in my jerk enchiladas with habanero-sour cream sauce. This jerk pork butt also works well with tacos, nachos, quesadillas, tostadas and burritos. And, of course, you can't go wrong with a jerk pork sandwich.

Feel free to get creative with how you serve this pork, and let me know any fun ideas you might have.

Perfect Pairing

Looking for a refreshing beer pairing? Try a double IPA. Roasted pork generally pairs well with malty beers, and a double IPA has a more malt-forward profile than a single IPA. Plus, you'll love how the earthy hops help bring out the spice.

Or maybe you're in the mood for a glass of wine. I like a malbec with this Caribbean pork dish. Malbec is a fruity, berry-forward wine that matches nicely with our warm spices, and its medium tannins stand up well to the fatty pork.

And, of course, any kind of Caribbean-inspired dish was made for a tropical co*cktail. My coconut margarita, strawberry-kiwi margarita or watermelon-coconut mojito make for fun options. Or you could go with a classic tiki co*cktail like this Painkiller.

For your next summer gathering, I hope you try this Jamaican jerk pork shoulder. After one bite, you'll want to make this dish a summer tradition.

Cheers!

Looking for More Summer Meal Ideas?

If you love this recipe, please leave a comment with a five-star rating — or simply hit the five-star button in the recipe card. Don't forget to sign up for my newsletter, and you can follow me on Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest and TikTok.

📖 Recipe